RULES AT YOUR FINGERTIPS Adventurer

Rule

Villainous Activities

Homebrew · IVD · 2024

Content Warnings: Physical and psychological torture, gaslighting, Stockholm syndrome.

A marking of some of the worst villains is their willingness to coerce others through violence and/or deceit in all their extremes. Not all villains make use of these extremes, but some will, and role-playing through that type of scene (whether the villain is a player or an NPC) is often inappropriate for most games. These rules aim to simplify such activities down to a single die roll or series of die rolls so that stories containing such content, with the use of safety tools, can still be told at the table. These rules do not seek to emulate real torture (which is rarely effective at anything but cruelty), but rather the way it appears in media. Specifically, these rules focus on the psychological outcomes of such torture rather than simply inflicting physical harm.

Before including these rules in the game, be sure to discuss their use and the level of detail desired in a session zero, and determine which safety tools you wish to use. For example, the Lines and Veils safety tool will help you set boundaries on how much detail and whether or not your group wishes to role-play torture scenes, while the Rose, Thorn, and Bud safety tool is a great way to check in with your players after such a scene and determine whether any changes should be made to the boundaries you have set. Likewise, X-cards allow anyone at the table to immediately end a scene if it becomes uncomfortable for them for any reason — no explanation necessary. If anyone in your group is remotely uncomfortable with the inclusion of torture, don't include it in any way.

The times and number of days (number of checks) required to attempt Weaken Mind and Convert Mind, or to help a creature recover from the Convert Mind effect, are set with a fast-paced adventure in mind. For slower adventures, you should triple or even quintuple the number of checks needed.

Torture

Real people suffer intense psychological and in some cases physical disability following torture. If you wish to include these effects in your game, it is recommended you do some research into the common effects and how they present themselves; the NIH (National Institutes of Health) and CVT (Center for Victims of Torture) have articles to help you in this process. Ultimately, the decision to have a lasting impact from torture should be the player's choice (if their character is the victim), or the GM's choice (if the victim is an NPC). Healing these effects should be done through role-playing, and at the GM's discretion a calm emotions spell could suppress these effects (e.g. the negative emotions associated with reliving a traumatic experience) for the duration of the spell, which may aid in this process. For a mechanical representation of this healing process, use the method presented under Convert Mind below.

The Torture Check

Once each day, a torturer can spend at least 4 hours with their victim, needling them with words, and inflicting physical and/or psychological harm, inducing fear in the victim while simultaneously convincing them that the torturer should be their friend. At the end of each such period, the torturer makes a Torture ability check using their Strength, Dexterity, Intelligence, or Charisma, determined by the GM depending on the torturer's method. The torturer adds their proficiency bonus, if any, for either Deception or Intimidation. The ability score used for the check depends on the method used by the torturer (e.g. Dexterity to cause precise lacerations, or Charisma to twist a conversation to inflict psychological harm).

The DC of the check is equal to 8 + the target's Constitution or Wisdom saving throw modifier (Constitution for a Strength or Dexterity check, or Wisdom for an Intelligence or Charisma check). Each success brings the torturer closer to using one of the actions described below. The DC for the saving throws for these actions is equal to 8 + the torturer's proficiency bonus + the torturer's Intelligence or Charisma modifier (whichever is higher).

Weaken Mind

The torturer weakens a target's mind and extracts a complete, truthful answer. The target makes a Wisdom saving throw, and on a failure must completely and truthfully answer a single question that the torturer asks of them. The question must be answerable in one sentence or a list, though the target may respond with more if they wish (i.e. Who else is a spy? Who do you serve? What were your orders?). This action can only be used against a creature against which the torturer has made 3 consecutive successful torture checks. Using this action resets the number of successful checks accumulated against a target of torture.

Convert Mind

After sufficient torture, a mind is broken. After 10 successful torture checks against a creature, the torturer can begin to twist its mind into a tool for their own use. Each day that the torturer takes this action, the creature must make a Wisdom saving throw or become charmed by the torturer. A creature charmed by the torturer in this way readily and willingly serves the torturer and their ideals until it can be convinced not to (for examples in media, look at Darth Vader's creation and redemption, as well as the Second Sister presented in Jedi: Fallen Order or Reek/Theon Greyjoy from Game of Thrones). Creatures normally immune to charm effects can still be affected by this action, although they have advantage on the saving throw. A creature that has failed its most recent saving throw against Weaken Mind has disadvantage on the saving throw against this ability. Using this action resets the number of successful checks accumulated against a target of torture.

Aiding a creature in returning to their senses, convincing them to abandon their torturer, or otherwise deprogramming them from their conversion is a long and difficult process. Once each day, a creature can spend at least 2 hours in conversation with the converted creature and then make a Charisma (Persuasion) check against the torturer's save DC. After 10 successful checks, the creature is no longer charmed by the torturer.

Rushed Torture Check

If a character tries to intimidate another creature via torture over a much shorter period of time than a normal Torture check, that character makes an Intimidation or Torture check against the normal Torture DC. The DC increases by 5 if the check is made in under 10 minutes. On a success, the creature complies with their demands, though it still has its own free will and may lie about its intentions (i.e. what it will do after being released). This check does not count toward the Weaken Mind or Convert Mind actions.

Consequences of Condoning or Conducting Torture

Using torture will make a character decidedly evil in the eyes of the players, but also in the eyes of most gods. On the other hand, some gods and other powerful beings (probably evil ones, such as Asmodeus) will see the character as a potential servant, or may even gain power from the pain inflicted on others regardless of the character's intention. Attitudes of gods and their churches toward the character should change to reflect differences or similarities in ideals. This also extends to the political world, depending on the social implications of torture — or at least open knowledge of its use. You should also consider the path that using torture will set your character on. Is it a point of no return for them, or can they be redeemed? What will that look like for them?

Quick preview