Rule
Inflicting Injuries on NPCs and Monsters
Homebrew · IVD · 2024
A PC may declare their intent to inflict an Injury against a non-PC creature as part of an action that requires an attack roll. When they do, they choose an aspect to target:
- Attacks (claws, teeth, weapons, etc.)
- Defenses (resistances and immunities)
- Mobility (movement)
- Special Attacks (such as a breath weapon)
- Special Mobility (e.g. flight, burrow, teleportation, invisibility — as long as there's a body part associated)
If they deal enough damage over the entire action to reach an Injury threshold, they inflict the Injury of any threshold they meet (i.e. if a PC deals enough damage with their action to hit the Handicap threshold, they may choose to apply either the Handicap or Dangerous Injury for the aspect they chose). Any damage resistance is applied before comparing the damage dealt against Injury thresholds. If the character makes one or more weapon or unarmed attacks as a bonus action during the same turn in which they attempted to inflict an Injury as part of an action, damage from the bonus action is combined with the character's action when determining whether an Injury threshold was met.
If the aspect has already been Injured at that severity, the attacking character may choose to inflict an Injury to that aspect of higher severity instead, up to the next highest severity that the aspect has not yet been Injured at. This type of action can only be made using single target attacks. If the action allows multiple targets for the attacks, only the designated Injury target can suffer an Injury, and only the damage to that target can be applied towards the Injury threshold.
Damage Loss
Regardless of whether or not a threshold is reached, the character's action deals less damage as indicated in the NPC Injury Thresholds table below. This damage reduction is applied after comparing damage against Injury thresholds.
Example. Dara, a cleric of slaughter, wants to inflict an Injury on the troll she faces. She declares she is targeting its Attacks, and casts inflict wounds at 4th level, dealing 22 damage. The troll has 84 health, so it falls into the 75 hit point tier, meaning that 22 damage inflicts an Injury of Dangerous severity. It suffers a necrotic wound to its arm, giving it disadvantage on the first Claw attack roll it makes each turn. The spell also deals 5 less damage, meaning the troll loses 17 hit points. Dara still has a bonus action left, and she cast spiritual weapon on a previous turn at 3rd level. She decides to take a gamble and inflict another Injury with its attack, again choosing to target Attacks. She hits, dealing low damage: 10. The attack does not meet any of the troll's thresholds, thus it does not inflict an Injury. However, the damage loss still applies, meaning the attack only deals 5 damage.
NPC Injury Severities
- Dangerous: The creature has had a very serious but survivable Injury inflicted, such as a deep slash to its muscle.
- Handicap: The creature has had a traumatic Injury inflicted, such as a cracked bone or partially severed tendon.
- Deadly: The creature has had a nearly lethal Injury inflicted, such as a broken limb, a severed extremity, or a damaged eye.
Identifying Strengths and Weaknesses to Target for Injuries
Once per turn (no action required), a character can make an Arcana, Religion, Nature, or Insight check (depending on the creature type) to identify strengths and weaknesses of an opponent to target for an Injury. The DC for this check is 10 + ¼ the creature's CR, rounded up. On a successful check, you learn a piece of information which helps you to choose an aspect to target for Injuries. For example, you might learn the creature has no abilities that require saving throws, making Special Attacks a bad choice, or that it has several damage resistances to types that you or your allies deal, making Defenses an excellent choice to target. You might also learn that a creature has a trait that increases or decreases its thresholds against specific damage types. For every 5 by which you surpass the DC, you learn an additional piece of information about the creature. You may not reattempt this check.
Example. Dara is fighting a vampire bloodlord and wants to know its best aspects to target. A vampire is undead, and therefore requires religious knowledge, so she makes a Religion check. She beats the DC by 5, and learns that the vampire has a number of resistances that she may want to Injure via the Defenses aspect, and several abilities (its turning bite and sanguine pool) that can be Injured via the Special Attacks aspect.
Adjusting NPC Injury Thresholds
NPC and monster Injury thresholds have been determined as a rough percentage of hit points, and based on estimates of average damage that various classes can put out at levels one would expect them to fight creatures of various hit point thresholds. If the thresholds are too low or too high for your particular party, or you want certain monsters to have higher or lower thresholds than normal, you should absolutely feel free to adjust them. Different groups have characters of different levels of optimization, and these rules are aimed at providing a useful average.
NPC Injury Thresholds
| Max HP | Dangerous | Handicap | Deadly | Damage Loss |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| <50 | 10 | 15 | 20 | 0 |
| 50 | 15 | 20 | 30 | 0 |
| 75 | 20 | 25 | 35 | 5 |
| 100 | 20 | 30 | 40 | 5 |
| 125 | 25 | 40 | 50 | 5 |
| 150 | 30 | 45 | 55 | 5 |
| 175 | 30 | 50 | 60 | 10 |
| 200 | 35 | 55 | 65 | 10 |
| 250 | 40 | 60 | 70 | 10 |
| 300 | 45 | 65 | 80 | 10 |
| 350 | 45 | 70 | 85 | 10 |
Death Blow
After being inflicted with a number of Injuries equal to its Constitution modifier (maximum 4), including one of Deadly severity, a creature becomes Imperiled. Whenever an Imperiled creature gains an Injury, it must immediately make a Constitution saving throw or die instantly. The DC for this saving throw is equal to 5 + the number of Injuries it has. The DC is increased by 5 if the creature's current hit point total is below half of its maximum hit points (applying any damage that was dealt as a part of inflicting the Injury first). A creature with Legendary Resistance can't use that trait to succeed on this saving throw. A creature can't inflict a Death Blow more than once per turn.
Attacks
- Dangerous. Choose one of the creature's attacks. It has disadvantage on the first attack roll it makes for that attack each turn. This Injury can be repeated, choosing a different attack each time.
- Handicap. Choose one of the creature's attacks. It loses its ability modifier on that attack's damage rolls. If the attack did not have an ability modifier damage bonus, it instead deals 1 fewer die of damage (minimum 1). This Injury can be repeated, choosing a different attack each time.
- Deadly. If the creature has natural weapon attacks, it loses one of them. If the creature could normally make two or more attacks with that weapon (i.e. claws), it only loses one of those attacks. If the creature uses manufactured weapons, it cannot make attacks with two-handed weapons unless it normally possesses more than two arms, and must choose whether to wield a one-handed weapon or a shield, but not both. If the creature currently has an item in each hand, the attacker chooses one of those and the creature drops it. This Injury may be repeated, choosing a different attack each time.
Defenses
- Dangerous. The creature's immunities to elemental and physical damage types become resistances. If a creature has more than two immunities, only two are reduced. Immunities are reduced at random. Necrotic, poison, psychic, and radiant damage are not affected. This Injury can be repeated for additional damage types.
- Handicap. The creature's resistances to elemental and physical damage types are lost. If a creature has more than two resistances, it loses only two of them. Resistances to the damage types dealt as part of the Injury are lost first, and are then randomly selected from the remainder. Necrotic, poison, psychic, and radiant damage are not affected. This Injury can be repeated for additional damage types.
- Deadly. The creature gains vulnerability to damage of the type that created the Injury. This Injury can be repeated for other damage types.
Mobility
- Dangerous. The creature's movement speed is reduced by 10 feet (to a minimum of 5 feet).
- Handicap. The creature's movement speed is reduced to half its current value (to a minimum of 5 feet). Any flat speed reductions or bonuses are applied first.
- Deadly. The creature must succeed on a DC 17 Constitution saving throw at the start of each of its turns or have its movement reduced to 0 until the start of its next turn.
Special Attacks
- Dangerous. Choose one of the creature's special attacks that deals partial damage on a miss or successful save. It now deals no damage on a miss or successful save. If the creature has no special attacks that deal partial damage on a miss or successful save, saving throws against one of its effects (attacker's choice) have advantage. This Injury can be repeated, choosing a different special attack each time.
- Handicap. Choose one of the creature's recharge abilities. It becomes one step less likely to recharge (i.e. a recharge 5–6 becomes recharge 6) until the end of the encounter. If the creature has no recharge abilities, its most damaging ability that allows a saving throw becomes a recharge 5–6 ability until the end of the encounter instead. This Injury can be repeated, choosing a different recharge ability each time.
- Deadly. The creature loses the ability to use one of its special attacks, chosen by the attacker when the Injury is gained. This Injury can be gained as many times as the creature has special attacks.
Special Mobility
- Dangerous. One of the creature's special movements (attacker's choice) has its speed or distance halved until the end of the encounter. This Injury can be gained multiple times, choosing a different movement each time.
- Handicap. The creature must make a DC 15 Constitution saving throw at the start of its turn or be unable to use one of its special movements (attacker's choice) until the start of its next turn. This Injury can be gained multiple times, choosing a different movement each time.
- Deadly. The creature can't use one of its special movements (attacker's choice). This Injury can be gained multiple times, choosing a different movement each time.
Note. Some creatures, such as an air elemental, have no walking speed, and instead rely on their Special Mobility to move. Such creatures tend not to have a biological reason for their Special Mobility, so it cannot be targeted. In this case, the creature is immune to both Mobility and Special Mobility Injuries.
Other creatures, like a fire elemental, are made of the thing they are immune to. Such creatures cannot lose their immunities to those damage types.